Boris Johnson's Comeback: A Gamble For The Tories?

Aria Freeman

5 min read

Post on May 03, 2025

4.7

Share

The Appeal of a Boris Johnson Return

Despite the controversies that have dogged his premiership, the appeal of a Boris Johnson return remains surprisingly strong within certain segments of the Conservative party.

Johnson's Remaining Popularity

• Strong support among grassroots Conservatives: Many Tory members remain loyal to Johnson, viewing him as a charismatic and effective leader who delivered Brexit.
• Positive polling data in specific demographics: While overall approval ratings may be mixed, some polls suggest continued high levels of support among older voters and those in traditionally Conservative-leaning areas. Further analysis is needed to understand these trends.
• A perceived strength on the national stage: Some believe that Johnson possesses a unique ability to connect with voters on a national level, a skill that could prove crucial in a future general election. His ability to project a certain brand of optimism could be a compelling counterpoint to the current political climate.

The "Johnson Brand"

Johnson's political persona remains a powerful asset. His communication style, characterized by a blend of humor and apparent sincerity, has proven effective in reaching a broad electorate.

• Effective use of rhetoric and populist messaging: Johnson's success in the 2019 general election demonstrates his ability to craft and deliver a compelling narrative to a mass audience.
• Charisma and relatability (perceived or real): His unconventional style and perceived connection with everyday concerns are seen by some as crucial ingredients for political success. Many see this as a key differentiator from his successors.
• Proven track record (despite scandals): Despite his controversies, supporters point to achievements such as delivering Brexit as evidence of his leadership capabilities.

The Risks of a Johnson Resurgence

However, a Boris Johnson comeback is fraught with peril. The potential downsides for the Conservative Party are considerable.

Lingering Scandals and Controversy

The shadow of "Partygate" and other controversies continues to loom large.

• Damage to the Tory party's reputation: Further investigations or revelations could severely damage the party's credibility and standing with the public. This risk cannot be underestimated, especially among moderate voters.
• Negative media attention: A Johnson return is almost guaranteed to trigger intense media scrutiny, potentially overshadowing the party's other policy initiatives. Managing this negative press will be a significant challenge for the party.
• Ethical concerns and public trust: Many voters remain deeply concerned about the ethical standards of the Johnson administration, and his return could reignite those concerns, harming public trust in the Tory party.

Division Within the Conservative Party

A Johnson comeback could exacerbate existing divisions within the Conservative Party.

• Deepening factionalism: Many senior Tories remain deeply opposed to Johnson's leadership style and the controversies that surrounded his premiership. His return would likely deepen internal divisions.
• Impact on party unity and stability: The party may struggle to maintain unity and focus on key policy goals amidst the inevitable infighting a Johnson return would likely cause. This could lead to further instability.
• Key figures and opposing viewpoints: The potential for open conflict between prominent figures within the Tory party cannot be ignored. This is a significant risk and has the potential to destabilize the party further.

Impact on the Wider Electorate

The reaction of the wider electorate to a Boris Johnson comeback is uncertain but potentially damaging.

• Alienating swing voters: Many swing voters may find a Johnson return off-putting, potentially costing the Tories crucial votes in a general election.
• Boosting Labour's prospects: A Johnson comeback could galvanize Labour support, providing a much-needed boost to Keir Starmer's leadership. This shift could prove decisive in the next election.
• Long-term electoral implications: The long-term impact on the party's electoral prospects could be profound, potentially making it more difficult for the Tories to win future elections.

Alternative Scenarios and Potential Outcomes

Several scenarios are plausible, each with significant consequences.

If Johnson Returns:

A successful Johnson return could see a short-term surge in Tory support, but this might be unsustainable if scandals resurface or internal divisions persist. It could also signal a shift towards a more populist, right-wing agenda for the party.

If Johnson Doesn't Return:

This opens the door for other potential leaders, creating an opportunity for the party to move beyond the controversies of the Johnson era and present a more united front. However, it might also lead to ongoing internal struggles for dominance.

The Impact on the Labour Party:

A Johnson comeback could significantly benefit the Labour Party, offering a clear and potent opposition narrative to rally supporters and attract undecided voters.

Conclusion: Assessing the Gamble – Is a Boris Johnson Comeback Worth the Risk for the Tories?

The potential for a Boris Johnson comeback presents a significant gamble for the Conservative Party. While his remaining popularity among some factions and his undeniable political skill offer potential advantages, the risks of reigniting old controversies, exacerbating internal divisions, and alienating swathes of the electorate are considerable. Ultimately, the decision of whether to welcome him back hinges on a complex calculation of short-term gains versus long-term stability and electoral viability. What are your thoughts on a potential Boris Johnson comeback? Share your opinions on this political gamble in the comments below!