Disney's Snow White Remake Vs. The 1987 Horror Version: Unexpected Parallels

Aria Freeman

3 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.5

Share

H2: Shared Narrative Structure

Both the Disney remake and the 1987 horror film, Snow White, follow the fundamental narrative structure of the original fairytale. The core elements remain: the jealous Evil Queen, Snow White's escape into the forest, her refuge with the seven dwarfs, and the climactic confrontation with the Queen. However, the execution and pacing drastically differ.

• Mirrored Plot Points: Both versions feature the Queen's poisoning attempt, Snow White's apparent death, and the Prince's arrival.
• Adaptation Differences: The Disney version emphasizes whimsical charm and musical numbers, while the 1987 film uses gothic horror aesthetics and a more adult storyline.
• Pacing and Tone: Disney's remake likely maintains a faster, family-friendly pace, contrasting sharply with the 1987 film's slower, suspenseful build-up to terrifying moments. The overall tone shifts from lighthearted fantasy to dark, psychological horror.

H2: The Portrayal of the Evil Queen

The Evil Queen is a central figure in both adaptations, yet her portrayal varies significantly.

• Motivations: In Disney's version, the Queen's vanity and desire for ultimate beauty drive her actions. The 1987 horror film may explore deeper psychological motivations, potentially linking her malice to trauma or a deeper-seated darkness.
• Visual Representation: Disney's Queen is likely to be visually striking, yet glamorous, while the 1987 version might present a more unsettling, grotesque, or even subtly terrifying image.
• Narrative Impact: In Disney, the Queen serves as a clear-cut antagonist. The 1987 horror film may present a more complex villain, blurring the lines between good and evil, adding layers of psychological depth and making her a more nuanced threat.

H2: Themes of Beauty, Power, and Deception

Both the Disney remake and the 1987 horror film explore the enduring themes of beauty, power, and deception inherent in the Snow White story.

• Beauty: Disney's version might focus on superficial beauty versus inner beauty, possibly providing a modern update. The 1987 film may subvert the traditional notion of beauty, possibly showcasing the Queen's beauty as a mask for her sinister nature.
• Power Dynamics: Disney's adaptation may explore power dynamics through the lens of female empowerment. The 1987 version might focus on the Queen's abuse of power and its corrupting influence.
• Deception and Manipulation: Both versions employ deception and manipulation as key plot devices. Disney's approach will likely be more straightforward, while the horror version might use more subtle and psychological manipulation.

H2: The Impact of Different Audiences and Time Periods

The target audience and cultural context significantly influence the interpretation of the Snow White story.

• Family-Friendly vs. Mature Themes: Disney's family-friendly approach contrasts sharply with the 1987 film's mature themes, reflecting the evolving social norms and expectations of each era.
• Evolving Perceptions of Fairytales: The adaptation of classic fairy tales reflects societal changes. The Disney remake will likely offer a more modern take, while the 1987 film reflects the darker, more psychological horror trends of its time.
• Societal Expectations: The portrayal of women and power structures evolves with time. Comparing the two films showcases how societal expectations and morals influence storytelling.

Conclusion:

The comparison between Disney's Snow White remake and the 1987 horror version reveals unexpected parallels. Despite their contrasting styles, both adaptations maintain the core narrative structure, explore similar themes, and feature a compelling portrayal of the Evil Queen. The significant differences, however, highlight the adaptability of the Snow White tale and its ability to resonate across diverse genres and time periods. Explore the fascinating world of Snow White adaptations; dive deeper into the contrasting portrayals of the Snow White Remake vs. 1987 Horror Version and discover the surprising similarities in the Snow White story across different genres!