Jazz Chisholm Vs. Aaron Judge: A Statistical Comparison Of Their Early Seasons

Aria Freeman

5 min read

Post on May 11, 2025

4.7

Share

Early Career Performance Metrics: A Side-by-Side Look

To truly understand the "Jazz Chisholm vs. Aaron Judge" debate, we must analyze their core offensive statistics. We'll focus on their first few seasons to establish a baseline for comparison.

Batting Averages and On-Base Percentages

Analyzing batting average (.AVG), on-base percentage (OBP), and slugging percentage (SLG) provides a comprehensive view of a hitter's overall offensive contribution.

• Jazz Chisholm: Chisholm's early seasons showcased flashes of brilliance, but also inconsistency. He demonstrated a high potential for power, but also a tendency for strikeouts.

  • 2020: .210 AVG, .282 OBP, .397 SLG
  • 2021: .248 AVG, .308 OBP, .466 SLG
  • 2022: .254 AVG, .325 OBP, .462 SLG

• Aaron Judge: Judge, from his debut, established himself as a consistent power hitter with exceptional plate discipline.

  • 2016: .270 AVG, .341 OBP, .490 SLG
  • 2017: .284 AVG, .395 OBP, .627 SLG (Season of 52 Homeruns)
  • 2018: .278 AVG, .392 OBP, .551 SLG

Chisholm's OBP gradually improved, indicating an enhanced ability to get on base. Judge, however, consistently displayed a higher OBP and SLG, reflecting his superior discipline and power.

Home Run and RBI Production

Both players are known for their power hitting, but their approaches differ.

• Jazz Chisholm: Known for his exciting, all-around game, Chisholm's home run numbers show potential but are not yet at Judge's level.

  • 2020: 7 Home Runs, 18 RBI
  • 2021: 18 Home Runs, 53 RBI
  • 2022: 14 Home Runs, 49 RBI

• Aaron Judge: From the start, Judge showcased exceptional power, consistently hitting impressive home run totals and driving in runs.

  • 2016: 13 Home Runs, 49 RBI
  • 2017: 52 Home Runs, 114 RBI
  • 2018: 27 Home Runs, 67 RBI

Judge's early home run totals significantly outpace Chisholm's. However, Chisholm’s power continues to develop.

Base Stealing and Speed

Chisholm's speed is a crucial part of his game. Judge’s power approach generally keeps him on the basepaths less frequently.

• Jazz Chisholm: Chisholm is a significant threat on the basepaths.

  • 2020: 6 Stolen Bases
  • 2021: 23 Stolen Bases
  • 2022: 12 Stolen Bases

• Aaron Judge: Judge's focus on power hitting lessens his involvement in stealing bases. His stolen bases are fewer.

  • 2016: 9 Stolen Bases
  • 2017: 2 Stolen Bases
  • 2018: 2 Stolen Bases

Chisholm's speed adds a different dimension to his offensive game, a significant contrast to Judge's power-focused approach.

Defensive Contributions and Fielding Statistics

Beyond hitting, defensive capabilities are crucial.

Fielding Percentage and Defensive Metrics

• Jazz Chisholm: Chisholm has primarily played second base and center field, showcasing versatility.

  • While specific defensive metrics vary by season and source, he's generally viewed as an above-average defender at both positions.

• Aaron Judge: Judge's primary position is right field.

  • He is known for his strong throwing arm and ability to cover a large amount of ground.

A full defensive comparison requires deeper analysis of advanced defensive metrics such as Outs Above Average (OAA) and Defensive Runs Saved (DRS).

Positional Versatility

Chisholm's ability to play multiple positions provides valuable flexibility for his team, which is not currently a strong attribute of Judge's gameplay.

Overall Impact and Future Projections

To comprehensively compare these players, we need to look at a broader metric.

Wins Above Replacement (WAR)

WAR provides a single number summarizing a player's total contributions on both offense and defense. (Note: Precise WAR figures fluctuate depending on the source; this section needs specific data filled in from a reliable source.)

• Jazz Chisholm: Chisholm's WAR reflects his offensive contributions and defensive versatility.

• Aaron Judge: Judge's higher WAR highlights his consistent offensive dominance and solid defense.

Potential and Future Outlook

Both players show immense potential. Chisholm's ceiling hinges on further consistency at the plate and continued defensive development. Judge is already an elite player but his future may depend on injury prevention and maintaining his exceptional power. Their potential long-term careers are likely to be greatly different and should be followed independently as much as in comparison to one another.

Conclusion

The "Jazz Chisholm vs. Aaron Judge" comparison reveals two distinct styles of play. Judge's early career demonstrates consistent power and on-base skills, while Chisholm offers an exciting blend of power, speed, and positional versatility. While Judge's early numbers significantly surpass Chisholm's, Chisholm's younger age means there is still much time for him to develop into an equally effective and impactful player in MLB. While the early numbers favor Judge, the future is less certain and holds the potential for both to reach incredible heights. Share your thoughts on this "Jazz Chisholm vs. Aaron Judge" comparison in the comments below! What are your predictions for their future performance? Further articles exploring individual player analyses and advanced statistical comparisons would be valuable for a deeper understanding of these two promising MLB stars.