MLB DFS Lineup Advice: May 8th Sleeper Picks And One To Fade

Aria Freeman

4 min read

Post on May 16, 2025

4.1

Share

Top Sleeper Picks for May 8th MLB DFS

Finding value in your MLB DFS lineup is crucial for success. These under-the-radar players offer high potential for significant returns relative to their salary.

Brandon Nimmo – OF, New York Mets

• Rationale: Nimmo is a high-on-base percentage hitter who excels against right-handed pitching. With a favorable matchup against a pitcher with a high ERA, he presents excellent DFS value. His recent performance shows a consistent ability to get on base, setting him up for a potential breakout game. He's currently underpriced considering his skills and the matchup.

• Key Stats:

  • .300+ batting average against right-handed pitching over the last two weeks.
  • High OBP (on-base percentage) consistently above .400.
  • Multiple hits in three of his last five games.

• Matchup Advantage: Facing a pitcher with an ERA over 5.00, and playing at Citi Field, a hitter-friendly stadium. This presents a high ceiling for fantasy points.

Bobby Witt Jr. – SS, Kansas City Royals

• Rationale: Witt Jr. is a young, dynamic player with immense potential. While his consistency may be lacking, his high ceiling makes him a compelling sleeper pick. His power and speed combination offer a significant upside for DFS. This hidden gem offers a high reward compared to the potential risk.

• Key Stats:

  • Recent increase in power numbers, with multiple extra-base hits in his last few games.
  • Above-average stolen base potential.
  • Good batting average against certain pitching styles.

• Matchup Advantage: Facing a pitcher who struggles against left-handed hitters, a favorable matchup for Witt Jr.'s hitting style.

Alec Bohm – 3B, Philadelphia Phillies

• Rationale: Bohm is an under-owned player with significant upside. His recent hot streak, combined with a favorable matchup, makes him a DFS steal. He’s shown consistent power and batting average recently, making him a solid value play.

• Key Stats:

  • High batting average over the past week.
  • Consistent production of extra base hits.
  • Improved plate discipline and contact rate.

• Matchup Advantage: Facing a pitcher with a history of giving up home runs to left-handed hitters, presenting a significant power potential for Bohm.

One Player to Fade on May 8th

Not every high-profile player is a good DFS choice. Sometimes, it's more valuable to identify players to avoid.

Shohei Ohtani – SP/DH, Los Angeles Angels

• Rationale: While Ohtani is a phenomenal player, his high salary makes him a risky pick for DFS. His recent pitching performance has been inconsistent, and his batting average has dropped. The combination of high cost and potential for underperformance makes him a player to fade today.

• Supporting Stats:

  • High ERA in recent starts.
  • Decreased batting average and on-base percentage.
  • Facing a strong opposing lineup.

• Matchup Disadvantage: Facing a team with a high-powered offense that consistently produces runs.

Building Your Optimal MLB DFS Lineup on May 8th

Creating a winning lineup requires more than just picking individual players. Here are some crucial considerations:

Salary Considerations: Balancing your budget is vital. You need to mix high-priced, proven performers with cost-effective sleeper picks like the ones we've highlighted to maximize your return.

Positional Needs: Pay attention to the specific positional requirements of the DFS contests you’re entering to ensure your lineup is valid.

Stacking Strategies: Consider stacking multiple players from the same team, especially if they are facing a pitcher they have historically performed well against. This strategy amplifies your potential points if the team performs well.

Conclusion

This MLB DFS lineup advice for May 8th has provided you with valuable insights into potential sleeper picks and a player to avoid. Remember to leverage these suggestions while considering your own research and risk tolerance. Building a successful MLB DFS lineup involves careful analysis and understanding of various factors. By incorporating these sleeper picks and avoiding the recommended player, you'll significantly improve your chances of winning big. So, confidently build your lineup and dominate your MLB DFS contests today! Remember to check back for more daily MLB DFS lineup advice.