MLB DFS Picks May 8th: 2 Sleeper Picks & 1 Hitter To Avoid

Aria Freeman

4 min read

Post on May 15, 2025

4.0

Share

Two Promising MLB DFS Sleeper Picks for May 8th

Identifying value is crucial in MLB DFS, and these two sleeper picks offer excellent potential for high point totals relative to their salary.

Sleeper Pick #1: Bobby Witt Jr. (Kansas City Royals)

• Recent Performance & Trends: Witt Jr. has shown signs of breaking out, with a recent uptick in his batting average and a noticeable increase in hard-hit balls. His speed also makes him a threat to steal bases, adding another dimension to his fantasy value.

• Favorable Matchup: The Royals face a pitcher with a history of struggling against left-handed hitters, and Witt Jr.'s left-handed swing could be a significant advantage. This pitcher's ERA and WHIP stats this season indicate vulnerability. We're looking for a pitcher who is giving up a high number of hits and runs.

• Key Stats: While his overall average might not be flashy, his recent power surge, as evidenced by his last three games with a HR and 3 RBIs, makes him an intriguing DFS option.

• Why He's a Sleeper: His salary likely reflects his inconsistency, but his recent performance and favorable matchup suggest a breakout game is on the horizon. This presents significant value in your MLB DFS lineup. Don't sleep on the power and speed combination.

Sleeper Pick #2: Brandon Nimmo (New York Mets)

• Recent Performance & Trends: Nimmo's on-base percentage (OBP) has consistently been high, making him a valuable asset even on days he doesn't hit for power. He has shown an ability to get on base consistently, and even a single or two can yield significant DFS points given his OBP.

• Favorable Matchup: The Mets' opponent on May 8th is projected to start a pitcher with a history of allowing a high number of walks. Nimmo’s patience at the plate makes him well-suited to capitalize on this weakness.

• Key Stats: Nimmo’s high OBP, combined with his ability to hit for average, makes him a strong choice for consistent points.

• Why He's a Sleeper: While not always the flashiest hitter, his consistency and ability to get on base, even against tough pitching, make him a strong and reliable MLB DFS sleeper pick.

One MLB Hitter to Avoid in Your DFS Lineup on May 8th

While selecting strong hitters is key, knowing who to avoid is equally crucial in maximizing your MLB DFS success.

Hitter to Avoid: Aaron Judge (New York Yankees)

• Reasons for Avoiding: Despite his star power, Judge has been struggling recently. His batting average is down, and he's facing a pitcher known for his excellent control and ability to keep hitters off balance.

• Relevant Stats: Judge’s recent stats show a significant dip in performance. The pitcher he's facing has consistently demonstrated dominance against right-handed power hitters—Judge’s greatest strength.

• Risk Associated: Investing a significant portion of your DFS budget on a player struggling to perform against a tough matchup is simply too risky. The potential for a low point total outweighs the potential reward. Avoid a costly mistake!

Maximize Your MLB DFS Success on May 8th

To recap, for your May 8th MLB DFS lineup, consider Bobby Witt Jr. and Brandon Nimmo as promising sleeper picks, while avoiding Aaron Judge due to his recent struggles and a challenging matchup. By incorporating these MLB DFS picks and strategies into your lineup construction, you significantly increase your chances of winning. Remember, smart analysis and strategic choices are vital in this game. Use these picks to build your MLB DFS lineups for May 8th and check back for future updates and more winning MLB DFS picks!