School Suspension: Understanding The Long-Term Negative Effects

Aria Freeman

4 min read

Post on May 03, 2025

4.1

Share

Every year, millions of students face the consequences of school suspension. Shockingly, data reveals that suspension rates are disproportionately high among students of color and those from low-income families. This article explores the long-term shadow of school suspension, arguing that this seemingly simple disciplinary solution casts a devastating and long-lasting impact on students' academic, social, emotional, and overall well-being. We will examine the detrimental consequences and advocate for more effective, equitable alternatives.

<h2>Academic Consequences of School Suspension</h2>

<h3>Increased Risk of Academic Failure</h3>

School suspension directly correlates with academic failure. The missed instruction, coupled with the disruption to learning routines, significantly hinders a student's ability to succeed. Studies show a strong link between suspension and lower grades, increased absenteeism, and ultimately, higher dropout rates. For example, one study found that students suspended even once are significantly more likely to fail a grade and less likely to graduate high school.

• Increased likelihood of failing grades: Missing classes means missing crucial instruction and assessments.
• Difficulty catching up on missed coursework: The volume of missed material can be overwhelming, making it challenging to reintegrate academically.
• Negative impact on GPA: Lower grades directly affect GPA, reducing college acceptance chances and scholarship opportunities.
• Reduced college prospects: A lower GPA and higher absenteeism significantly diminish the likelihood of college admission.

<h3>Disruption of Learning Continuity</h3>

Beyond simply missing classes, suspension disrupts the continuous flow of learning. The social and emotional impact of being removed from the classroom can be just as detrimental as the missed academic content.

• Missed crucial lessons and assignments: These gaps in knowledge create a domino effect, making it harder to understand subsequent material.
• Difficulty re-establishing classroom routines and relationships: Returning to school can be isolating and overwhelming, making it harder to focus on academics.
• Feeling isolated and alienated from peers: Students who are suspended often feel disconnected from their classmates and teachers.

<h2>Social and Emotional Impacts of School Suspension</h2>

<h3>Increased Behavioral Problems</h3>

Suspension is often counterproductive, exacerbating existing behavioral problems rather than solving them. Instead of fostering positive change, it can contribute to a cycle of escalating behavioral issues. The removal from a structured learning environment can reinforce negative behaviors and increase the risk of future disciplinary actions, contributing to the troubling "school-to-prison pipeline."

• Development of negative attitudes toward school: Suspension can instill resentment and distrust towards the educational system.
• Increased likelihood of future suspensions or expulsions: A history of suspension often leads to further disciplinary problems.
• Strained relationships with teachers and peers: The stigma of suspension can make it challenging to rebuild trust and positive relationships.

<h3>Mental Health Implications</h3>

The emotional toll of school suspension is considerable. Students often experience heightened anxiety, depression, feelings of isolation, and hopelessness. The negative effects can extend to increased risky behaviors, including substance abuse and self-harm.

• Higher rates of depression and anxiety: The stress and social isolation associated with suspension can trigger or worsen mental health issues.
• Increased risk of self-harm or suicidal thoughts: Feeling alienated and hopeless can lead to dangerous behaviors.
• Difficulty forming healthy relationships: Social isolation and negative experiences can make it difficult to build positive relationships.
• Increased risk of substance abuse: Students may turn to substances as a coping mechanism for the stress and isolation.

<h2>The Disproportionate Impact of School Suspension</h2>

<h3>Racial and Ethnic Disparities</h3>

A critical concern is the disproportionate suspension rates for minority students, particularly African American and Latino students. This overrepresentation highlights systemic biases within school disciplinary practices.

• Bias in disciplinary practices: Implicit biases can lead to harsher punishments for minority students compared to their white peers for similar offenses.
• Lack of culturally responsive teaching strategies: A lack of understanding of cultural differences can lead to misunderstandings and disciplinary actions.
• Socioeconomic factors impacting student behavior: Poverty and other socioeconomic factors can contribute to behavioral challenges that are often addressed through suspension.

<h3>Alternatives to Suspension</h3>

Fortunately, effective alternatives exist. Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) and restorative justice practices offer more constructive approaches to discipline.

• Conflict resolution skills: Teaching students to resolve conflicts peacefully is crucial.
• Counseling services: Providing access to mental health support can address underlying behavioral issues.
• Restorative justice circles: These circles bring together students, teachers, and administrators to collaboratively address harmful actions and find solutions.
• Positive behavior reinforcement systems: Rewarding positive behavior is far more effective than solely punishing negative behavior.

<h2>Conclusion: Rethinking School Discipline and the Negative Effects of Suspension</h2>

The long-term shadow of school suspension is undeniable. Its negative consequences extend far beyond the immediate disciplinary action, impacting students' academic progress, social-emotional development, and future opportunities. The disproportionate impact on minority students further underscores the urgent need for systemic change. We must move beyond punitive measures and embrace alternatives like PBIS and restorative justice practices. Let's prioritize creating supportive and inclusive school environments that foster positive behavior and academic success for all students. Learn more about restorative justice practices and advocate for policies that mitigate the long-term negative effects of school suspension and promote a more equitable educational system. Let's work together to break the cycle and build a brighter future for all students.