The Harmful Effects Of School Suspensions: A Critical Analysis

Aria Freeman

5 min read

Post on May 03, 2025

4.7

Share

Academic Consequences of School Suspensions

School suspensions significantly disrupt a student's academic progress, creating a ripple effect that can impact their entire educational trajectory.

Increased Absenteeism and Falling Grades

Suspensions directly lead to increased absenteeism, resulting in missed classes, crucial lectures, and vital learning opportunities. This missed instruction translates into difficulty completing assignments and performing poorly on tests.

• Missed curriculum: Students miss core subjects, falling behind on essential concepts and skills.
• Difficulty catching up: The backlog of missed work can be overwhelming, making it challenging to regain academic ground.
• Impact on GPA: Missed assignments and lower test scores inevitably lead to a decline in grade point average (GPA), potentially affecting future educational opportunities. This academic performance decline is a significant consequence of school suspensions.

The cumulative effect of these factors contributes to significant learning loss and negatively impacts academic performance. This educational disruption can have lifelong consequences.

Increased Risk of Dropping Out

A strong correlation exists between school suspensions and higher dropout rates. Suspensions often mark a turning point in a student's relationship with school, pushing them toward disengagement and ultimately, leaving school entirely.

• Statistics showing the link: Numerous studies demonstrate a clear link between repeated suspensions and increased likelihood of dropping out of high school.
• Cycle of suspension and disengagement: Suspensions can create a vicious cycle. Students who are suspended may feel alienated and less connected to their school community, leading to further behavioral issues and increased risk of future suspensions.
• Impact on future opportunities: Dropping out of high school severely limits future educational and employment opportunities, hindering overall life chances. School expulsion, a more severe disciplinary action, further exacerbates these negative outcomes.

Social-Emotional Impact of School Suspensions

Beyond the academic realm, school suspensions inflict significant damage on students' social-emotional well-being.

Damage to Self-Esteem and Mental Health

The experience of suspension is often deeply humiliating and isolating. Students may feel stigmatized, ashamed, and disconnected from their peers and school community. This can lead to a decline in self-esteem, increased anxiety, and even depression.

• The emotional toll on students: Suspension is a traumatic experience for many students, leading to feelings of rejection and abandonment.
• Potential for increased aggression or withdrawal: Some students may react with increased aggression, while others may withdraw socially, further isolating themselves.
• Impact on peer relationships: Being suspended can damage relationships with peers, making it difficult to reintegrate into the school community. This social isolation significantly impacts emotional well-being.

Increased Risk of Involvement in the Juvenile Justice System

School suspensions contribute significantly to the "school-to-prison pipeline," a troubling trend where school disciplinary actions lead to involvement with the juvenile justice system.

• The "school-to-prison pipeline": Suspensions often serve as a gateway to more severe disciplinary measures, leading students down a path towards involvement with law enforcement.
• Lack of support systems post-suspension: Students returning from suspension often lack adequate support and resources to help them reintegrate successfully into school, increasing their risk of future disciplinary actions.
• The correlation between suspension and criminal activity: Studies show a clear correlation between repeated school suspensions and increased likelihood of involvement in criminal activity. This disciplinary action is a key component of the issue.

Long-Term Effects of School Suspensions

The negative repercussions of school suspensions extend far beyond the immediate consequences, impacting students' long-term prospects.

Reduced Future Opportunities

School suspensions leave a lasting mark on a student's record, creating significant obstacles to future opportunities.

• Challenges accessing higher education: College admissions officers often consider disciplinary records, making it more difficult for students with suspensions to gain admission to higher education institutions.
• Impact on employment background checks: Suspensions may appear on background checks, potentially hindering employment prospects.
• Lifelong consequences of a negative school record: The long-term consequences of a negative school record can significantly limit a student's life chances, impacting their ability to achieve their full potential.

The Need for Alternative Disciplinary Practices

Addressing the harmful effects of school suspensions necessitates a shift towards alternative disciplinary approaches.

• Examples of effective alternatives: Restorative justice practices, positive behavior interventions and supports (PBIS), and conflict resolution programs offer more effective and equitable ways to address student misbehavior.
• Benefits of these methods: These alternatives focus on rehabilitation, teaching students valuable life skills, and fostering a more positive and inclusive school environment.
• Focusing on rehabilitation rather than punishment: By addressing the root causes of misbehavior and providing support to students, these alternative discipline strategies promote positive behavior and reduce the reliance on punitive measures.

Conclusion

The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates the significant negative consequences of school suspensions on students' academic success, mental health, and future opportunities. The high suspension rates disproportionately affect marginalized student populations, exacerbating existing inequalities. Understanding the harmful effects of school suspensions is crucial. Let's work together to advocate for more equitable and effective disciplinary practices—reducing school suspensions and promoting alternative approaches—that prioritize student success and well-being, fostering a supportive learning environment for all. We need to move beyond punitive measures and embrace strategies that support students' holistic development and prevent them from falling into the trap of the school-to-prison pipeline. Reducing school suspensions is not just about changing disciplinary actions; it's about creating a more just and equitable education system.